2 good open source PDF readers

Published on

Spent some time this morning looking into different PDF readers. The default document viewer on Ubuntu is Evince. It works, no significant complaints, but overall I think I read enough PDF’s that a little more full featured, or nicer reader might be… nice. Found a decent comparison article, a bit outdated, but still helpful. I want to stick with open source, and in that vein I also found this nice little site which I will definitely be pointing people to in the future. (What is the best way to use those link buttons to compliment the grails PDF plugin that I work on?) Okular looked like a the most promising alternative, so I did a quick install via Synaptic, it’s meant for KDE so it brought a bunch of dependencies along with it. After the install completed it started up no problem on my Gnome desktop. I see some things I like, but I am not sold just yet. However, a few nice features and UI polish can go a long way, time will tell. To do my initial comparison I used the latest issue of Full Circle, which is a pretty cool e-zine. What I found out is that both of these readers do pretty well. Where Evince wins is simplicity and speed. Also it seems to render images a little better and text a little faster, judging just by appearance it looks like it has smarter anti-aliasing. For all I know this rendering advantage could reverse if I were in KDE. Probably the most negative thing I have to say about Okular is that the thumbnails looked pretty bad. The images in the thumbnail previews were great, better than Evince by a bit, but the text was rendered really poorly when the thumbnails were small. Now where Okular wins. It has a nicer desktop icon (how pretty is that! ) and I like its default UI layout and options better. It has some really cool (and useful) features that Evince just can’t match. The three I played with were Bookmarks, Reviews and Selection. I did find out a couple features of Evince that I was unaware of, and I subsequently added a handful of buttons to the toolbar that in my opinion should be there by default. My loose conclusion is that I will keep Evince around and use it to view shorter documents that I don’t need to interact with much, and I will used Okular for things like reading e-books.